Skip to content

Who Has the Power?

9 courses, in the order they are meant to be taken. You can start anywhere, and they build.

How to read the course codes
  • -00 means start here.
  • -01, -02 are steps on one path, in order.
  • A letter (-T1, -P2) marks a track. Tracks run in parallel: take any track you like, in any order, without taking the others.
  • -99 is the capstone. Take it last.

The path

  1. POWER-01

    Who Has the Power to Do This?

    Step 1 on the single path through this series.

    A method course for reading government authority. Given any government action, a zoning change, an annexation, a school-district line, a police stop, a tax, a permit denied, you will learn to find four things from the public record: the BODY that acted, the ENABLING AUTHORITY it claimed, the DOCUMENT that grants that power (a constitution, a charter, a statute, an ordinance, or a treaty), and WHO CAN OVERTURN IT. It is the general case of which the route series is fourteen worked examples: find the instrument, then find its source. Along the way it teaches the fact most adults were never taught, that in the United States cities are creatures of the state (Dillon's Rule, the Cooley Doctrine, home rule, and preemption), the vertical stack of authority from the nation down to the special districts almost nobody votes for, and the idea that tribal nations are not a rung on that ladder at all but a separate sovereign whose authority predates the United States. This course teaches how to READ authority. It is not legal advice.

  2. POWER-02

    Forms of Government, Honestly

    Step 2 on the single path through this series.

    A course about the labels we put on governments, and why sorting the world's states into 'democracy,' 'autocracy,' 'monarchy,' or 'republic' is a contested argument, not a vocabulary quiz. It is course 2 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, taught you to read authority from the primary record. Here you learn the classical forms and what they actually mean (democracy, republic, monarchy, autocracy, oligarchy, theocracy), and then the harder and more useful skill: how to read a classification critically. The heart of the course is that the four major measurement projects, V-Dem at the University of Gothenburg, the Polity project, Freedom House, and the Economist Intelligence Unit's Democracy Index, rank the same countries differently, on published methodologies, because they define democracy differently and measure different things. You will learn what each project measures, who codes it, and the four reasons their rankings diverge, especially for the hard cases in the middle: hybrid regimes, competitive authoritarianism, one-party states, and constitutional monarchies that are functionally democracies. It closes with a map of who measures democracy and from where, and a capstone: classify one real country by two different indices and explain the gap between them from the published methodologies. The course never asserts a country's current score from memory; it teaches you to read the current report yourself.

  3. POWER-03

    How Countries Constitute Themselves

    Step 3 on the single path through this series.

    The course about the constitution itself: the document course 1 kept walking the chain of authority up to, and the machinery every country builds to say who holds power and how it is limited. It is course 3 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, already taught the four questions and the vertical stack, and it treats that course as its prerequisite. You will learn to read any constitution on three axes. The first is the horizontal question: who holds executive power, and how is it linked to the legislature? That is the difference between a parliamentary system (where the executive sits in the legislature and survives on its confidence), a presidential system (where a separately elected president holds executive power for a fixed term), and a semi-presidential system (a president and a prime minister at once), and you will learn the trade-offs and the genuine scholarly fight over whether presidentialism is more fragile and whether semi-presidential is even a coherent category. The second axis is territorial: federal or unitary. The third is the form: codified into one written document or uncodified and scattered, as in the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and Israel, and rigid or flexible to amend. Then the course turns to how constitutions are actually made, taught through four real cases on four routes: the United States in 1787 by a convention that then had to be ratified, South Africa in 1996 by a negotiated transition a court had to certify, Japan in 1947 by a text the occupying power largely wrote, and Germany in 1949 by Germans drafting at home inside limits the Allies set. It closes with a world map of constitutional systems and a capstone: trace how one real constitution was made and classify its system from the primary documents. This course teaches how to read authority. It is not legal advice.

  4. POWER-04

    The Middle Layer: States, Provinces, and Regions

    Step 4 on the single path through this series.

    The course about the level of government between the nation and the locality: the US state, the German Land, the Canadian province, the Spanish autonomous community, and the devolved nations of the United Kingdom. It is course 4 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, already taught the four questions and the vertical stack, and it sits directly above course 5, The Local Layer. Its one load-bearing idea is the difference between federalism and devolution, taught as entrenched versus delegated. A United States state is a co-sovereign: its existence and its equal representation in the Senate are bolted into the Constitution, and the federal government cannot abolish it. Scotland's powers, by contrast, come from the Scotland Act 1998, an ordinary Act of the Westminster Parliament that, under the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty, Parliament could in principle repeal. That distinction, whether a middle-layer government holds its power by constitutional entitlement or by a statute the center can rewrite, is the whole lesson. You will learn the US reserved powers and the anti-commandeering doctrine, why a state cannot be abolished, and interstate compacts; then Germany's Laender and the Bundesrat, Canada's provinces under the Constitution Acts of 1867 and 1982, and Spain's contested estado autonomico; then the United Kingdom's asymmetric devolution and the sovereignty question at its heart. It closes with a map of federal, devolved, and unitary systems and a capstone: classify a real subnational government as entrenched-federal or devolved, and defend it from the primary documents. This course teaches how to read authority. It is not legal advice.

  5. POWER-05

    The Local Layer

    Step 5 on the single path through this series.

    The course about the level of government most adults were never taught: the city, the town, the county, and the tens of thousands of single-purpose special districts that tax people who cannot name them. It is course 5 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, already taught the four questions and introduced Dillon's Rule. This course develops that introduction into the real machinery of local power. You will learn Dillon's Rule and home rule as a spectrum rather than a slogan, and why state preemption can wipe out a local ordinance the week after it passes. You will learn the forms of municipal government, mayor-council (strong and weak), council-manager, and commission, and exactly what each one changes about who decides. You will meet the special districts that in the United States outnumber municipalities, learn why they exist and why almost nobody votes in their elections, and read a real one. You will see the New England town meeting, where the residents are the legislature, and then Unigov, where in 1969 the Indiana legislature redrew a major city overnight, by statute, with no referendum, the purest demonstration of the fact that in the United States a city is a creature of the state. It closes with a capstone: document every local government and special district over your own address, from the primary record. This course teaches how to READ authority. It is not legal advice.

  6. POWER-06

    Tribal Nations and Indigenous Governance

    Step 6 on the single path through this series.

    The course that develops the one correction most civics teaching gets wrong: a tribal nation is not a rung on the federal, state, and local ladder at all. It is a separate sovereign, and its authority is pre-existing and inherent, older than the United States, not delegated down a stack the way a city's power is delegated from a state. Course 1 of this path, Who Has the Power to Do This?, introduced that idea in a single section; this course earns it in full, and with the care such content requires. You will learn where tribal sovereignty comes from and why the Marshall Court called the nations domestic dependent nations; why treaties rank as supreme law under the Supremacy Clause and how courts read them; how nations govern today, the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 and its model constitutions set against traditional and customary governance, with the Haudenosaunee Confederacy as a named living case; and the hard legal edges, Public Law 280, McGirt v. Oklahoma, and Alaska Native corporations, which are corporations rather than reservations and are the sharpest crossover between this path and the business-forms path. This course leads with nations' own words and Indigenous scholarship, treats the 574 federally recognized tribes as 574 distinct governments, and stops deliberately short of any nation's ceremonies or restricted internal detail, because that is not the course's to give. It teaches how to read authority. It is not legal advice.

  7. POWER-07

    Governments Without States

    Step 7 on the single path through this series.

    Course 7 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, taught the four questions (who acted, under what authority, where the power comes from, who can overturn it) and the vertical stack of national and subnational government. This course is about the authority that stack leaves out: governance that happens in bodies that are NOT sovereign states. It opens with the question underneath the whole subject, what even makes a state a state, teaching the Montevideo Convention's four criteria (1933) and the long argument between the declarative and constitutive theories of recognition. Then it climbs above the state to the supranational bodies: the European Union, which is neither a country nor an ordinary treaty organization but its own autonomous legal order (Van Gend en Loos, 1963; Costa v ENEL, 1964); the United Nations, an organization of sovereign equals rather than a world government (UN Charter, 1945); and the African Union (2002), successor to the OAU. Then it turns to the hardest case, unrecognised and contested states, taught neutrally: the course describes the recognition disagreement, attributes each claim, reports the documented facts, and does not adjudicate anyone's status. Finally it comes down BELOW the state to self-governing communities, the homeowners association that governs by covenant, the housing co-op that governs by membership, the union that governs by collective bargaining, and the mutual-aid network that governs by voluntary agreement, which is the hand-off to the business path, because each holds its power through an entity and an instrument rather than through sovereignty. It closes with a capstone: find a body with real authority over someone that is not a sovereign state, and map where its power comes from. This course teaches how to read authority. It is not legal advice, and it does not take sides in any sovereignty dispute.

  8. POWER-08

    How Power Changes Hands

    Step 8 on the single path through this series.

    The course about the moment authority moves from one set of hands to another, and it has two halves. The first half treats elections as machines: the same ballots, counted under different rules, produce different winners. You will see one identical set of votes seat three different candidates under three different systems, and then learn the moving parts that make that happen: first-past-the-post and the two-party pull of Duverger's law, wasted votes and the spoiler effect, party-list proportional representation, district magnitude and thresholds, ranked-choice or instant-runoff, and mixed-member proportional. The claim underneath all of it is that the counting rule, not the votes alone, picks the winner, which is why changing the rule is itself a way of changing who holds power. The second half leaves the ballot box for the routes power takes when elections are not the mechanism: coups seized from inside the state, revolutions driven from below, negotiated transitions like Poland's Round Table in 1989 and South Africa between 1990 and 1994, and term limits as a design choice that schedules the handover in advance. It is course 8 of the path whose method course, Who Has the Power to Do This?, taught the four questions, and it is the general case of that course's fourth question, who can overturn it, asked about the rulers themselves. It builds on that method and complements the constitution course without repeating it. This course teaches how to read the rules by which power changes hands. It is not legal or political advice, and it takes no side in any contested election or dispute.

Finish here

  1. POWER-99

    Capstone: Map Your Own Stack

    Capstone. Take it last: it works by using what the rest of the series taught you.

    The capstone of the path, and its last course. You have learned the method (find the body, its enabling authority, the document that grants it, and who can overturn it), the middle layer of states and provinces, the local layer of cities and the special districts that outnumber them, tribal nations as a separate sovereign, and the governments that exist without a state at all. Now you put the whole toolkit to work on the one place you know best: the block you live on. This course teaches you where each layer's PRIMARY RECORD actually lives, the state constitution and its statutes, the county or city charter, the special district's enabling act and the assessor and elections offices, tribal jurisdiction, and an HOA's recorded covenants, and how to find the document for each. Then it sets the graded capstone: document every government with authority over your block, cite the primary record for each, and note which ones surprised you. Most people find six to twelve, and are surprised by half. It closes with a rubric you grade yourself against. This course teaches how to READ authority. It is not legal advice, and it never asks you to publish anyone's private address or parcel data, including your own.